The Good Doctor Actors Open Up About How They Got Cast On The Show

The Good Doctor seems to have interesting story arcs on the show as well as in the real-life of its cast. From Freddie Highmore almost being replaced to the casting of an actor who actually comes from a medical family, the show is brimming with fun trivia. Here are some crazy casting and other behind the scenes stories.

Image Credits: Getty Images / The Good Doctor cast


If you’re still reeling from Dr. Neil Melendez’s unexpected death, you’re not alone. At least there’s a silver lining: he got to proclaim his love to Dr. Brown. But over to real life! Gonzalez is well-known for his incredible roles in Resurrection Blvd and Narcos, among others. 

Image Credits: WireImage via Getty Images / Greg Doherty / Actor Nicholas Gonzalez attends the 2018 PaleyFest Los Angeles - ABC's "The Good Doctor" at Dolby Theatre on March 22, 2018 in Hollywood

The first thing that drew him to Melendez was the impressive team behind the show. But more than anything, it was the writing. Gonzalez praises writer David Shore for his deft stroke that is neither melodramatic nor heavy-handed. Well, with Shore’s credits ranging from Traders, Law & Order and House, M.D., it’s no surprise that Gonzalez seized the opportunity.  

He first heard about the audition for The Good Doctor in January 2017. According to Gonzalez, pilot seasons are always crazy and actors rarely get enough time to prepare. He’s had to audition up to four times a day before and this was no different. But he knew he had to knock it out of the park to secure the role. 

Everyone who’s anyone was in the room during his first audition. This included the actor and the show’s producer, Daniel Dae Kim, who he immediately recognized from Lost and Hawaii Five-0. Sounds like a stressful situation. But while he was nervous, Gonzalez calmed himself with his motto, “no one can do you.” And he got the role! 

He can’t remember much about the audition, just that “it wasn’t a lot”. It all makes sense when you learn that his first child with his wife, Kelsey Crane (yes, also from The Good Doctor set) was six days old when he had to shoot the pilot! He was ecstatic about the role along with the newest addition to his family. 

Image Credits: Flickr / Gage Skidmore / CC BY-SA 2.0 / Nicholas Gonzalez speaking at the 2016 Wondercon, for "Bordertown", at the Los Angeles Convention Center

There’s another fun little fact. In real life, most of Gonzalez's family works in medicine! His father and brother are surgeons. His mom on the other hand, works at a Radiology Center. Not only that, his brother even acted as an uncredited medical consultant in an episode of The Good Doctor. Talk about a talented family. 


Apart from playing Dr. Alex Park, Will Yun Lee is also known for his roles in Altered Carbon, The Wolverine and Hawaii Five-0! Lee moved to Hollywood in 1997 with only $1,000 dollars in the bank - and his dream of acting

Image Credits: Getty Images / Dimitrios Kambouris | Will Yun Lee attends Netflix's "Altered Carbon" Season 2 Photo Call at AMC Lincoln Square Theater on February 24, 2020 in New York City

It’s Bruce Lee’s story that inspired him to pursue acting. As an accomplished martial artist himself, Will Yun Lee went to UC Berkeley on a sports scholarship and majored in ethnic studies, telling CAA Media that his studies: “changed [his] perception of how [he] fits in the world and gave [him] touchpoints for being bold and taking chances.” 

Clearly being bold and taking risks paid off for him. Much like Gonzalez, Lee had something huge going on in his personal life that overlapped with The Good Doctor casting process. However, while Gonzalez’s event was a happy one, the same couldn’t be said for Lee and his wife, Jennifer Birmingham (yes, also from The Good Doctor). 

Starting in 2017, their then three-year-old son, Cash, suffered a lot. You won’t believe the odd timing, though. “We came home in recovery. We turned on the TV and there was an episode [of The Good Doctor]…we started crying because it was about Shaun dealing with this one kid.” A few months later, Lee landed a part in the show. 

Image Credits: Getty Images / Will Yun Lee


Have you heard the sad news yet? David Shore officially announced that Dr. Carly Lever will not return in Season 4. According to Express UK, Nicole was stung by this blow and has her own theories about why she’s not been asked to return. 

Image Credits: Getty Images / Gabe Ginsberg | Actress Jasika Nicole attends the ClexaCon 2017 convention at Bally's Las Vegas on March 4, 2017 in Las Vegas, Nevada

In June this year, she tweeted a reply to an enthusiastic fan: “Unfortunately, I was not asked to return to the show next season.” She went on to say that the situation was “very disappointing” and that she feels she was used as a prop to push forward the other white characters’ narratives.

Image Credits: Getty Images / The Good Doctor cast

On the other hand, David Shore told TVLine, “I love Jasika, and would love to see her on the show, but it will not be in the same capacity.” Well, we’re in no position to speculate about these matters and think it’s best left there. Dr. Lever was a great addition to the show and she’ll surely be missed. 


Schiff who portrays Dr. Glassman is also known for his role in The West Wing, during which he also made his editorial debut. Schiff revealed to Deadline that, “I’d never seen [Shore’s] House, because I don’t watch doctor shows.” However, since he had a personal connection to the autistic community, when he saw the script, his interest was piqued! 

Image Credits: Getty Images

He recalls asking his friend Eli who had worked on The West Wing and House. He asked him about what it’s like to work with Shore - and Eli’s response hugely affected Schiff’s decision. “David’s a fantastic guy. Really fun and great to work with. By the way, they really, really love you for this.” And the rest was history. 

Remember in season 1, when Dr. Glassman was interested in Debbie? You might be surprised to know that Sheila Kelley, the actress who played Debbie is Schiff’s wife! They have been married since 1987. "She originated the entire worldwide industry of pole dancing as fitness. People should look her up." He is still head over heels in love with her.


Thomas says she loves playing Dr. Claire Browne because she's a ball of contradictions. In reality, the British actress also somewhat leads a double life. For about two years, her work overlapped! She was in two TV shows at the same time. One was Lovesick, a very British rom-com and the other, The Good Doctor, a very American medical drama. 

Image Credits: WireImage via Getty Images / Mike Marsland | Antonia Thomas attends The Olivier Awards 2019 with MasterCard at the Royal Albert Hall on April 07, 2019 in London, England

"I get to flex very, very different skills and that's what keeps me excited about this job. I wouldn't have it any other way”, she told Now to Love. While casting for pilot season, you’d think Freddie Highmore would be signed first. But things worked out quite differently. In fact, Thomas got the role before Highmore had even been discussed. 

In an interview with Build, Thomas revealed that her audition call came in at the last minute. She was in LA, enjoying some downtime with a girlfriend after a week of auditions. The moment the call came in, she went home and practised. The next morning, she was surprised because she wasn’t expecting the producers and the director to be present. 

She told Digital Spy her audition included medical jargon too. Being British, she had to prepare it in American English too. "It was quite a lot of work, and I definitely walked in thinking, 'Ugh, this isn't going to go my way.' But it all worked out!" She’s clearly a professional, having aced the audition with so little prep time! 

Image Credits: Getty Images


Apart from being Dr. Marcus Andrews, you also know him from his roles in the CSI franchise. Did you know that the actor’s Dad was a psychiatrist? His Mom was one of the first African American practicing anaesthesiologists! Wow - another actor whose family hails from a medical background. 

We just have to mention - Harper himself has multiple Ivy League degrees and honorary doctorates, ranging from law to public administration. Not just a pretty face, he’s also written several books. We couldn't find much about his audition for Dr Andrews - pretty sure it’s because they grabbed him with both hands when they saw him! 

According to Harper, the show’s success is down to its compelling storylines. “Everything starts with the writing. It is grounded in something that’s bigger than the actual story.” In an interview with the Build series, he praised the team of writers and David Shore. He also sang Freddie Highmore’s praises as an actor and human being, saying they’d hang out together when filming is done. 

Image Credits: /Getty Images for The Lions NY / Ilya S. Savenok / Hill Harper attends the The Lions X WDC World Ocean Day Event at Spring Place on June 08, 2019 in New York City

Harper thinks the series is so successful among viewers, because it addresses important and meaningful topics, like autism. Fans are so moved by the episodes that they sometimes share with him how they’ve been personally affected. He uses his social media accounts to interact with them, live-tweeting the show as well as applauding his talented co-stars. 


Dr. Shaun Murphy might fool you with his American accent, but Highmore is as British as they come. You’re not alone in thinking Freddie does a stellar job of portraying Dr Murphy. So that makes it even more unbelievable to hear that he almost didn’t accept the role!

Image Credits: Getty Images for SCAD / Vivien Killilea | Actor Freddie Highmore speaks at the "Bates Motel" event during aTVfest 2016 presented by SCAD on February 6, 2016 in Atlanta, Georgia

When Shore approached Highmore, he had just finished Bates Motel - and he only had hours to decide. He told Adweek, “When you’ve just finished a show that had been on for five seasons … you need to choose wisely because you could end up [doing] something that you might not want to for years and years.” 

While we’re ecstatic he accepted the role of Dr. Murphy, chances are high that he’s going to be taking an extended vacation once The Good Doctor is done. To be specific, he only had three days off between Bates Motel and The Good Doctor. We are surprised he didn’t run out of energy. 

Image Credits: GC Image via Getty Images / RB/Bauer-Griffin | Freddie Highmore is seen at 'Jimmy Kimmel Live' on March 02, 2020 in Los Angeles, California

Highmore was drawn by the light humor and the "moments of joy" in the script. He was also excited for getting the opportunity to work with David Shore and his amazing story. Another reason he decided on the show, was because of Shaun, the fascinating character that he gets to play. 

Speaking to, he said Murphy required way more preparation than any previous role. It was important to portray his condition authentically. “I had personal relationships with people who have autism even before this came along. But aside from that, I watched documentaries, read pieces of literature and we had an autism consultant who…continues to be part of the show.” 

Image Credits: Getty Images / Freddie Highmore

Apart from being an amazing actor, Highmore also wrote the script for season 2’s premiere. He’s also a producer and director on the show. It was his idea to have 18 episodes for each season, instead of the usual 23 episodes. “It’s the idea of making the show…good…You’d never want to just be doing more for the sake of it.” 

The Good Doctor really had its share of intrigue right from the stage of casting. We are so excited for season 4 and all the new exciting additions to the show. Which casting stories surprised you the most?

You May Also Like